On Thursday night I attended the dress rehearsal for an upcoming opera, Wagner's
The Flying Dutchman. Opening night was on Saturday.
 |
| Promotional image used by NZ Opera for The Flying Dutchman |
I've only been to one other professional opera in my life, and that was Madame Butterfly. These works were quite different in many ways! And I have to say, I'm glad that I got to see the Puccini (Madame Butterfly) first, as The Flying Dutchman had a few qualities that would not make it a good show for first-time opera-goers. I don't like to write less than commendatory reviews, but to stay true to my honest opinion it must be done, in this case. And it's not that I regret going, I still enjoyed seeing the performance and having the experience.
Firstly, while the plot lines of operas are notoriously slow, The Flying Dutchman was still unexpectedly slow-moving, and didn't really have much of a story at all. The plot is, as one may have guessed, the story of the Flying Dutchman, who has been condemned to an eternity at sea. He can only be saved if he finds a wife who will stay faithful until death, but he is only allowed ashore to seek a wife once every seven years.
The opera begins at sea, with a vessel full of sailors headed home. The Dutchman comes across this ship and speaks with the captain, offering all his riches for shelter for one night, and the captain's daughter's hand in marriage. The captain accepts, and they head ashore.
This concludes the first act. No female roles have been introduced yet - the second act begins with the women's choir and the female lead, Senta, working away making clothes (and nude male dummies to put the clothes on...). Senta is the captain's daughter, and as it happens she is infatuated with the story of the Flying Dutchman, and has a picture of him on the wall. She sings the ballad of the Flying Dutchman, which is perhaps the high point of this opera.
Just so that things aren't too straightforward, Senta does already have a "lover" of sorts. There is a hunter who believes that he and Senta are to be married, and who has taken care of Senta while her father has been away at sea. Naturally he is very upset by Senta's infatuation with the Flying Dutchman, and has dreamt that Senta will marry the Dutchman when her father returns. However, the audience isn't really given much opportunity to feel sympathy for this hunter, and indeed we don't really feel much sympathy for the Dutchman either. This lack of connection to the characters didn't help the show's overall effectiveness, and unlike Madame Butterfly, I didn't leave this opera feeling as if I had witnessed something powerful, even though Senta and the Dutchman both kill themselves at the end.
There are several choral numbers, and a large male and female choir. They sing separately (as in, male numbers and female numbers) and together. The abundance of songs featuring the choir seemed to make this opera lean undesirably towards the "musical theatre" genre, and the modern dress and mannerisms of the choir in the third act especially did not help this at all.
The theatrical effects were very cool, complete with "visions" of a (nude) female lover and a sailor spitting up blood. Especially effective were the Dutchman's sailors with their long hair, who stood up after many motionless minutes (silent through a large choral number) to reveal black, skull-like faces. The curtain that made up the back wall of the stage moved forwards to signify the waves of the ocean, and this backdrop softly fell at the end of the show to indicate the death by sea of the lead roles. Amusingly, the front curtain at the beginning of the show had the word "Overture" projected onto it as the orchestra was playing, which seemed a little unnecessary and even a little bit degrading.
The set was also very well constructed for the audience's benefit. The "ship" at the beginning was a minimalist-style box, with a ladder that went through the box's roof as the watchtower. This housed all the sailors (male choir) and captain. Impressively, the leads occasionally sang from the top of the ladder, on what must have felt like unstable grounding! Additionally, the stage was on a slope, so that the whole of the choir could be seen (which was probably not great for the singers' comfort either).
As for the actual music, well, there was nothing exceptionally moving and nothing exceptionally memorable. The orchestra is full of stormy strings doing chromatic runs, as Wagner often is, and calls from the horns, (some of whom were offstage), nothing too revolutionary. The songs were okay, nothing too impressive there either, even in the soprano's role. The "Ballad of the Dutchman", one of the soprano's songs, was one that I remember being good, but other than that, not much of the music stayed with me.
Overall, although the singers were fantastic and the production's set was very well constructed, this opera failed to live up to the high expectations that NZ Opera had set up for me with Madame Butterfly. The odd juxtaposition of the very modern with the non-modern didn't work for me and cheapened the experience, and for a Wagner opera, this was not the best choice to put on, especially here in New Zealand where we don't have the luxury of having the choice of multiple operas to go see and might appreciate the chance to see a lesser-known work (as may be the case in New York or bigger cultural centers).
currentVote
noRating
noWeight